Most Holy Trinity Church is famous for its numerous paranormal legends. Reports include unexplained footsteps throughout the four-story rectory, disembodied voices, and lights in the school gymnasium turning on and off by themselves. The church’s former sexton, George Stelz, was murdered in the vestibule in 1897, and legend has it that his spirit roams the parish and rings the church bells mysteriously.
Haunted Lineage note: Corrected address from 153 Johnson Ave to the official address at 138 Montrose Ave.
Built between 1882 and 1885 on a former cemetery, Most Holy Trinity Church is famous for its numerous paranormal legends. Reports include unexplained footsteps throughout the four-story rectory, disembodied voices, and lights in the school gymnasium turning on and off by themselves. The church’s former sexton, George Stelz, was murdered in the vestibule in 1897, and legend has it that his spirit roams the parish and rings the church bells mysteriously.
Imported from The Shadowlands Database
Discover documented hauntings, folklore, and spectral sightings within 15 miles of Most Holy Trinity Church.
📍 5.1 mi away
The Jewish cemetery is over a century old, and has hardly been taken care of. Though...
📍 8.8 mi away
Catering Hall – the place is haunted by two guys and a girl. At night you...
📍 12.9 mi away
The story goes that a couple who just got married were passing through the park on...
